Screaming and Beating: The Hidden Damage of Harsh Correction in Parenting

Parenting is one of the most profound responsibilities entrusted to humans, shaping the next generation and molding their character. While many parents resort to screaming or physical punishment to correct children, these methods often stem from frustration or cultural norms rather than evidence-based practices. Islam, as a comprehensive way of life, provides guidance on nurturing children with love, fairness, and wisdom. This article explores the causes of screaming and beating in parenting, their implications for parents, the effects on children across different age groups, and the Islamic perspective on discipline.

Causes of Screaming and Beating in Parenting

Screaming and beating are often impulsive responses, reflecting underlying struggles or societal influences.

1. Stress and Burnout
   Parents facing overwhelming stress—financial, emotional, or physical—may lash out when children misbehave, not because of the severity of the child’s actions, but due to their own inability to cope.

2. Cultural Norms
   In many cultures, physical punishment is normalized and seen as a "necessary" tool for raising obedient children.

3. Lack of Parenting Skills
   Some parents resort to screaming or beating because they lack knowledge of effective, non-violent disciplinary methods.

4. Past Trauma
   Parents who were themselves raised with harsh discipline often replicate the same patterns, sometimes unconsciously.

5. Unrealistic Expectations
   Parents may expect children, especially younger ones, to behave like adults, leading to frustration when those expectations are unmet

Implications for Parents

While these behaviors may seem effective in the short term, they often leave parents feeling guilty and exhausted.

1. Emotional Strain
   Constant yelling and beating create a cycle of anger, frustration, and regret. Parents may feel disconnected from their children as these behaviors erode the parent-child bond.

2. Increased Stress
   Instead of solving behavioral issues, screaming and beating often escalate tensions, leaving parents more stressed.

3. Spiritual Consequences
   Islam emphasizes gentleness in all matters, including parenting. The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said:

   “Indeed, Allah is gentle and loves gentleness in all matters” (Sahih Muslim, 2593).

   Engaging in harsh discipline may lead parents to feel spiritually distant or disconnected from Allah’s mercy.

Effects on Children Across Age Groups

The impact of harsh discipline varies by age but is universally harmful.

1. Early Childhood (0–6 years)

   • Effects: Fear, confusion, and hindered emotional development. Young children often cannot comprehend the reasons for harsh punishment, leading to insecurity and anxiety.
   • Islamic Perspective: The Prophet (ﷺ) demonstrated extraordinary patience with children, never resorting to harshness even when they disrupted prayers or misbehaved.

2. Middle Childhood (7–12 years)

   • Effects: Lower self-esteem, increased aggression, and difficulty trusting authority figures. These children may mimic aggressive behavior toward peers or siblings.
   • Islamic Perspective: At this age, children are encouraged to learn discipline, but the Prophet (ﷺ) instructed this to be done with wisdom and fairness:

     "Command your children to pray when they are seven, and discipline them for it when they are ten" (Abu Dawood, 495).

3. Adolescence (13–18 years)

   • Effects: Rebellion, resentment, and long-term psychological issues like depression or anxiety. Adolescents subjected to screaming or beating often distance themselves from parents.
   • Islamic Perspective: Adolescence is a critical period for building trust and open communication. Harshness at this stage can alienate children, contrary to the Prophet’s approach of nurturing relationships with kindness and dialogue.

Islam’s Approach to Discipline

Islam provides a balanced and compassionate framework for parenting.

1. Gentleness and Patience
   The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said:

   “The strong is not the one who overcomes people by his strength, but the strong is the one who controls himself while in anger” (Sahih al-Bukhari, 6114). 

   Parents are encouraged to model calmness and self-restraint.

2. Effective Communication

   • Islam emphasizes clear and calm communication. The Qur'an states:

     “…speak to them words of kindness” (Qur’an 4:5).

   • Explaining rules and consequences fosters understanding and cooperation.

3. Reward Over Punishment
   Positive reinforcement is a cornerstone of effective discipline. Rewarding good behavior builds intrinsic motivation and strengthens the parent-child bond.

4. Discipline as a Teaching Tool
   Disciplinary actions in Islam aim to correct behavior, not to vent frustration. The Prophet (ﷺ) exemplified this by addressing mistakes with wisdom and love, ensuring the dignity of the child remained intact.

Practical Alternatives to Screaming and Beating

1. Calm Down Before Reacting

   • Take deep breaths or step away momentarily to collect your thoughts before addressing the issue.

2. Set Clear Expectations and Consequences

   • Clearly outline acceptable behavior and the consequences of misbehavior in advance.

3. Use Logical Consequences

   • Tailor consequences to the misbehavior (e.g., restricting screen time for breaking screen time rules).

4. Engage in Positive Reinforcement

   • Praise and reward good behavior to encourage its recurrence.

5. Model Desired Behavior

   • Children learn more from actions than words. Demonstrating patience and kindness teaches them the same values.

6. Seek Help if Needed

   • Parenting can be overwhelming. Seeking support from family, friends, or professionals can help parents manage stress and adopt healthier approaches.

Screaming and beating may seem like quick fixes, but they carry long-term consequences for both parents and children. Islam offers a compassionate and effective alternative, emphasizing gentleness, wisdom, and patience in raising children. By adopting these principles, parents can foster a nurturing environment that not only corrects behavior but also instills love, trust, and respect.

Breaking the cycle of harsh discipline is a journey, but with self-awareness, effort, and reliance on Allah, it is achievable. As the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said:

“There is nothing that is gentler than gentleness, and there is nothing harsher than harshness” (Ahmad, 21407).

Let us choose gentleness— for the sake of Allah, then for our children's safety and future.

Visit islamqa for a detailed understanding of the Islamic view on screaming and beating children while correcting them